Welcome to Part 2 of Our Reader Mailbag
If you missed Part 1, you can catch up here. In this installment, I delve into some intriguing questions from our readers, including a heartfelt reflection on Johnny Gaudreau and a discussion about the NHL’s scheduling and player trades. Your questions are invaluable, providing me with insights into what’s on your minds as we navigate the NHL exhibition season.
The NHL Schedule: A Call for Reform
Andrea from Europe raises an important point about the NHL’s calendar. The current schedule, stretching from mid-September to the end of May, has long been a topic of contention. Reflecting on my first full season covering the NHL in 1980-81, I recall how the playoffs didn’t extend into June until 1992. The fact that a winter sport often concludes its season as summer begins seems absurd.
In an ideal world, I would advocate for a shortened training camp, a start date of October 1 for the regular season, and a 76-game schedule that wraps up playoffs by May 31. However, many U.S.-based teams prefer a later start to avoid conflicts with baseball playoffs and the NFL season. This reluctance to adjust the schedule is frustrating, especially considering that fans in Canada, Europe, and northern U.S. states likely share the sentiment that the season is too long. The solution is straightforward, but the will to implement it remains elusive.
Calgary Flames: Trade Speculations and Player Value
Ryan’s question about the Calgary Flames touches on the unrest among veteran players and the potential for trades. Jonathan Huberdeau, in particular, has seen his value plummet since signing a hefty contract. For Huberdeau to regain interest from other teams, he would need to return to being a point-per-game player. His current contract, with a staggering $10.5 million annual cap hit over seven years, makes him a challenging asset to move without Calgary retaining a significant portion of his salary.
Other players like Blake Coleman, Mikael Backlund, Nazem Kadri, and Mackenzie Weegar have varying degrees of trade value. Coleman, with his championship experience and recent performance, could attract interest from contenders. Backlund, despite his age, has expressed a desire to finish his career in Calgary, making a trade less likely. Weegar, a valuable piece in the Flames’ transition, would require a compelling offer to be moved. Kadri, while still effective, may not age well under his current contract, but could serve as a useful reinforcement for a team with a short championship window.
Edmonton Oilers: A Potential Trade for Seth Jones?
Mike poses an interesting scenario regarding a potential trade between the Edmonton Oilers and the Chicago Blackhawks, involving Darnell Nurse and Seth Jones. At first glance, the idea of swapping these two players seems appealing, especially given their similar contracts and the need for a right-handed defenseman in Edmonton. Jones has shown he can log significant ice time, while Nurse has struggled to match that level of production.
However, for Chicago to consider such a trade, Edmonton would likely need to include an attractive sweetener. While the symmetry of the trade is intriguing, it’s not clear that it would benefit both teams equally.
Old Cup-Winning Teams: Who Has the Best Chance for Another Championship?
Daniel’s question about which "old" Cup-winning team has the best chance to recapture their glory is thought-provoking. While teams like Washington, Pittsburgh, and Los Angeles seem unlikely to return to championship form, I wouldn’t count out the Tampa Bay Lightning just yet. With key players like Andrei Vasilevskiy and Nikita Kucherov still in their prime, Tampa Bay has the potential to make a deep playoff run. Their window for success remains open, unlike the other teams mentioned.
NHL Expansion: The Future Landscape of the League
John F. raises a compelling point about NHL expansion and the potential for relegation. While the idea of relegation has been discussed, it’s hard to envision it becoming a reality in North American sports. As for expansion, I believe the NHL could reach 40 teams eventually, but not without careful consideration. Cities like Atlanta, Houston, and Portland are likely candidates for future teams, but the league must tread cautiously to maintain competitive balance.
Succession Planning for Gary Bettman
Michael H. inquires about the succession plan for Gary Bettman. While he hasn’t publicly discussed it, I anticipate he will step down around 2027, at which point a search committee will likely be formed to find his successor. Bill Daly could be a candidate, but the NHL may also seek fresh perspectives from outside the current leadership.
Remembering Johnny Gaudreau
D.J. N. asks for fond memories of Johnny Gaudreau, and it’s hard to encapsulate the impact he had during his time in Calgary. His recent passing has left a profound void in the hockey community. Gaudreau was not just a talented player; he had a charisma that brightened the locker room. His genuine love for the game and his teammates was evident, and he was always eager to get back to work, even after contract negotiations.
One standout memory is from a 2019 interview where he expressed a desire to become a gym teacher after his playing career. This aspiration reflected his character—someone who genuinely cared about helping others. His thoughtful gestures, like ensuring accessibility in his summer home for a family member, showcased his kindness.
As we reflect on Gaudreau’s legacy, it’s clear that his spirit will be missed throughout the NHL this season. His infectious personality and dedication to the game made him a beloved figure, and the impact of his loss will resonate deeply within the hockey community.